Thursday, November 19, 2009

Dressing to impress

Librarians love to complain that our profession doesn't get enough respect. We went to the trouble of going through an advanced degree to get our jobs, so why does it seem like people don't recognize us as professionals?

Of course there are a number of historical reasons for this, but one that has struck me since becoming a librarian is the problem of our image. To be more specific: too many librarians dress like the stereotypical shushing spinster librarian. I consider myself an information professional, so when I get dressed before work in the morning, I make a point of attempting to look professional. And let me say from the beginning that this is all I'm asking of librarians: that they make the effort and *attempt* to look professional. I may not be an expert at colour coordination, and some may argue that wearing a sweater vest almost every day is a bit much, but I wear clothes that fit me well and that make me look like I'm at work to take care of some business. Unfortunately, this is not the case for many librarians, especially those who work behind the scenes and not directly with our clients (at McGill, we call our users *clients* because that's what other professionals call the people they serve).

Now, some would certainly disagree with me when I argue that even those librarians who sit by themselves at a desk deep in the belly of the library should dress professionally, and I do believe that image is especially important for those working on the front lines. But every librarian attends meetings, and every librarian walks in and out of the library, and every librarian represents both the library and the profession, so I believe that every librarian should dress like a professional.

I hope I'm not giving the impression that my colleagues dress like slobs, because that's certainly not the case. Many of them come to work every day looking ready to take on the world. But there are a significant few who need a serious image makeover, both for a professional career and often for the 21st century as well. Just attend a conference or any other large gathering of librarians, and you'll see what I mean.

I think one objection to dressing up more is that some librarians are afraid of anything that looks too corporate. It's true that we don't work for for-profit companies, but we can still dress nicely without looking like snake oil salespeople. And another likely objection is that we don't *have* to do it, so librarians would prefer to be comfortable. Well maybe we don't have to - but I really think we should. I think we should all dress for success, and make our libraries and our profession look as professional as we believe them to be.

How do you dress for work? Do you think we should all try to dress up, or is physical appearance merely superficial? Let us know in the comments.

Labels: , ,

15 Comments:

At 9:43 AM, Blogger MontglaneChess said...

As a library student/support staff person who works out of site of the public (for the most part), I try to err on the side of semi-professional. Because I switch between class and work with no time for changing, I often try to pair a nice shirt with jeans and nice shoes. During the winter, it is easier to "look professional" coming and going from the building as I invested in a nice, professional looking coat. When I work full-time during summers, I try to wear nicer pants (khaki, dress pants, etc) when I know I'll be spending some time wandering around the floor. If I'll be in the back all day, I won't try quite as hard (only because I'm not involved in staff meetings, etc).

 
At 9:43 AM, Blogger MontglaneChess said...

and...typo. sight, not site. (too much internet, clearly!).

 
At 12:10 PM, Anonymous Julia Brewster said...

I believe it is very important to portray a professional image which includes dressing as one! I happen to work in a corporate environment so I would feel very out of place if I didn't attempt to fit in with the dress code - however regardless of work environmnet I feel that if we want to be treated as professionals we should dress like professionals!

 
At 1:01 PM, Blogger Megan said...

I also very much agree that a professional look is important. I always make an effort to dress appropriately at work (and conferences!...even though I've been asked if I'm a vendor more than once). I'm also especially conscious of my dress since I'm often mistaken for a student.

But just to play devil's advocate a bit, there's also something to be said for looking natural and approachable. I certainly received more spontaneous reference questions when I was a student shelving books in jeans and a T-shirt than as a librarian in a suit behind a reference desk. Looking cool, relaxed, and friendly helps build a rapport with students. I think that casual dress can also inspire confidence in those who do more techy types of work.

And a funny aside: posted today by Pete on FriendFeed: Men in vests! http://friendfeed.com/lsw/e6c11334/it-friday-all-for-your-viewing-pleasure-here

 
At 2:01 PM, Blogger Jane said...

While I feel very strongly that emphasis should be on substance over style, I will concede that we should all look tidy and approachable.

I wear jeans at least two days out of five, trousers or a skirt the rest of them. I dress to the nines (i.e. a suit, heels and a skirt, etc.) when I feel it's necessary. When delivering instruction to a classroom full of MBA students, certainly, I wouldn't dream of showing up in jeans. But, if I know that I don't have much on the go besides a reference shift or a small meeting of my peers - it's jeans all the way.

Those who work with me everyday have noticed this as well - every time I am dressed up, I get an inevitable "so, teaching a class today, Jane?".

In the end - I would say wear what makes you feel good, but make sure its clean and it fits!!! And please, no flip flops or tank tops ... that's just not cool.

 
At 2:31 PM, Blogger Graham Lavender said...

Yay, Men in Vests! Where do I sign up? Or perhaps I'm already a member without even knowing it.

 
At 11:32 PM, OpenID michael said...

I, too, take time to dress "up" before I head out the door in the morning. I aim to look professional, hip, cool, younger than my gray hair would suggest, intelligent, happening, but at the same time unassuming not really not too vain. :)

In all seriousness, however, I think I have to agree with something Megan alluded to when she mentioned the jeans/reference-questions ratio: dressing for all of our audiences. We want, and should be taken seriously by the student community at our schools, but we need to always be approachable as well.


Incidentally, typing out these thoughts reminds me of how our profession sometimes doesn't know what it wants to be. We want the respect of our faculty and administrative peers and also more respect salary-wise (I'm thinking of your post right now, btw, Deborah!), so often we move about in those cultures, and often we do it well. But other times we deliberately set ourselves against the Faculty/Admin image in order to help the community understand what exactly we do and how it is that our specific skills and training help us to do it well.

But I digress. Whether its our wardrobe or wearing different professional hats, it's always a balancing act..

 
At 11:15 AM, Blogger Meghan said...

Siiiiigh. I am reading these comments on my Saturday shift. I showed up in jeans and a sweatshirt only to find a business school alum. event in full swing -- 300 ppl. in suits at 10am on Saturday. Don't I feel the fool! But Mon-Fri I dress like a real-live grown-up. I have to, otherwise people think I'm a student.

 
At 2:29 PM, OpenID biblioblond said...

When my library's union was putting pressure on our municipality during recent contract negotiations, one of their pressure tactics was to wear jeans. As I understand it, the idea was that the municipal officials would get upset that the library staff was not displaying a professional image for the city and that they would give into the union's demands. I thought this was extremely silly. Most of my work is conducted behind a desk and so generally patrons cannot see whether I’m wearing jeans, dress pants or a skirt. Also, I think that I maintained a professional appearance since my “normal” clothes, even my jeans, tend to be on the dressy side (my yoga pants are strictly for reading, baking, and well doing yoga).

Another key point that has not been mentioned explicitly is that regardless of others’ impressions of librarians, dressing professionally can make you feel more confident about yourself at your workplace. I’m not sure if there is research to back this up but I’m fairly certain that people who dress professionally are more efficient, motivated, productive, and self-confident. When I dress up and put on make-up before heading out to work, it is not so much to impress other people as it is to feel good about myself which allows me to better perform my job whether or not I am visible to the public.

 
At 5:34 PM, Blogger Jen said...

Everyone has an idea of what "professional" is and means. I think a lot of us actually think "corporate". What do professional engineers wear? Professors? What about your dentist or family doctor?

I try not to dress like a slob (anymore) but I do not dress like most other librarians either; I don't even own a suit at the moment (grew out of my last one). I'm not a "suit" and don't want to be one either. It's not that I'm afraid of corporate, as graham wrote, but corporate is dull.

I've been wearing skirts and dresses a lot more lately, but again, they aren't usually things that many of you would probably think to wear to work, and they wouldn't be suitable for a business firm or a law office atmosphere. I am just truly bored of suits. Ugh. I mean, I am planning on going suit shopping with a stylist soon, but they are just such extremely boring pieces of fashion!

If you're going to dress up, can you please spice it up a bit too? Maybe accessories would help.

 
At 6:39 PM, Anonymous Ahniwa said...

I enjoy dressing up to an extent; sweater vests and corduroy pants go a long way (long live the sweater vest!)

That said, I'm always happy I get to wear jeans on Fridays (though I can't bring myself to wear a t-shirt).

I don't actually work with the public much, and my forays outside are pretty well-planned, but I feel that it's important to dress like a "professional" all the same, and that means at least a little nicer than I dress at home.

Anyway, good post, Graham, and always happy to leave you comments. :)

 
At 9:27 AM, Blogger Jane said...

Hey everyone!

If you've been following this comment thread, you may be interested in this video from Ryerson's Career Centre. Something that hasn't been mentioned in the discussion is that a business wardrobe can be pricey. For a new grad, this poses an obvious problem.

Here's how to look professional without breaking the bank:

http://vimeo.com/7779630

 
At 3:32 PM, Blogger Megan said...

More discussion on how to dress (for profs!) on Prof Hacker

 
At 3:40 PM, Blogger Jen said...

Yeah, actually, I think profs need more advice than most librarians. I usually surprise them by wearing a nice dress while they're in t-shirts and jeans.
Oddly, that's mostly the male professors, females tend to dress a bit nicer in slacks and sometimes jackets. Is it a gender issue?

 
At 8:27 PM, OpenID bluestockinglibrarian said...

To echo what Megan said above, for me a large motivating factor comes from the desire to distinguish myself from the students. When I wear jeans and t-shirts on days I know I'll be doing manual labor, my co-workers literally don't recognize me because they think I'm a student. So it's heels and skirts for me!

 

Post a Comment

<< Home